The 1st wine was good but a bit closed: Clos L’Eglise 2009 ( 98 RP)
The 2nd wine, oaky, full, very concentrated, to be cellared for another 15/20 years: Gracia 2009 (98RP)
The 3rd wine was more accessible, a good wine, less concentrated, more classic: Haut Carles 2009 ( 92RP)
The 4th was, for me, the best and one of the very fine wines of Bordeaux. A must have: caressing, ripe, soft, sexy, really fine, with incredible texture…: Pontet Canet 2009 (100RP)
And finally, Haut Carles 2011 which I still believe is a great wine, not for snobs, nor for the label drinkers. This kind of wine should be served blind to prove that one can still find such great values in Bordeaux!